In the first 3 chapters of Wilhelm's "You gotta BE the book", he explores the many dimensions of reading and the literary thoeries that have informed the teaching and evaluation of reading for some time. I was imressed with his juxtaposition of New Criticism with ideas proposed by Rosenblatt. It made me realize that contemporary methods of teaching reading are highly influenced by the idea that the text creates meaning and it is up to students to find what that meaning is. This approach does not help students (or anyone else for that matter) connect to the text in a way that would allow them to enjoy what they are reading. It definitely becomes more of a task than something you do for leisure and excitement.
Thinking back to my days in middle school, I could completely relate to the ideas expressed by his students about reading. He noted that one of his students said that reading is something people tell you to do so that you can spew out the 'correct' answers. How doe sthis help students? This chapter really made me think of even ways that I wa stauht redaing and the deficits affected me. In grade school a 'good' reader wa sone who could read fast. It had little to do with actually understanding the text and allowing it to speak to your life.
Chapters 1-3 are positioned beautifully in the beginning of the book to set up a framework from which teachers should start. The author used examples of students who weren't the best readers to provide a foundational question of how to encourage students to read. I want to adopt this approach for my own classroom in efforts to learn from my students and provide assistance or modify the curriculum as it benefits my students. I also liked the idea of 'studying' my students, which beyond reading, will encourage a love for them as individuals.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment